Seven Samurai + 2

A Headless Body Production
Venue:   An Undisclosed Basement

Event:    Playing a game for the camera 
Players: Phil Gardocki running Korean
              Tom Worden running Samurai
Game System: L'Art de la Guerre, 15mm, 200 points per side.

Never Fight a Land War in Asia.  To fulfill this bit of wisdom, the commanders, Larry-San and Kim-Lar-Re agree to take their tête-à-tête to the grounds of the Leeside Football Club, next to the Lough Mahon, in Cork, Ireland.

The Forces:
Samurai (list 210)
The Samurai are commanded by Larry-San, the Strategist, his brother Darryl-San the Ordinary and his other brother Darryl-San, also Ordinary.
9 Samurai, Medium Swordsmen, Bow, Elite  
4 Yari, Medium Spearmen, Mediocre
4 Mounted Samurai, Heavy Cavalry, Bow, Elite  
2 Followers with Bow, Bowmen, Mediocre
Breakpoint of 19

Koryo Korean (list 212)

The Koreans are commanded by Kim-Lar-Re, the Competent, his brother Kim-Dar-El, the Competent, and his other brother Kim-Dar-El, also Competent.

2 Guardsmen, Heavy Cavalry Impact, Elite

2 Horsemen, Heavy Cavalry Impact, Ordinary

2 Militia Horsemen, Medium Cavalry Impact, Mediocre.

6 Spearmen, 1/2 Heavy Spearmen, 1/2 Crossbow
1 Cataphract, Elite
2 Light Cavalry, Bow
2 War Wagons, Crossbow
1 Light Infantry, Bow
1 Hwacha, Heavy Artillery.
1 Guardsmen, Crossbow, Pavise, Elite
Breakpoint of 21

The Hwacha artillery is a multiple barrel launcher, where each piece is a rocket propelled arrow, and some explosive material.  Up to 200 rockets could be fired in a few seconds.  Think of it as throwing 200 Rocket Propelled Grenades down range in about 10 seconds.  Mythbusters made and tested one on their show.  

The Board:
The Samurai win the initiative and elect to defend in the plains.
However, the one terrain piece that fell on their side of the board was removed with an adjustment die roll of "6".

The Samurai Cavalry deploys on the right.  They are supported by 3 units of foot Samurai with odd names.

The jokes in this frame are American centric, Leave a message if you get them. 

The rest of the Samurai army has their flank anchored to the Lough.

Holding the left flank are two War Wagons

The Korean center is a concentrated force of Crossbow armed Spearmen.

On the right are the mass of Cavalry.  It is Kim-Lar-Re's hope he will drive through the mediums, take the camp, and win the game.

Turn 1:

Hwacha doing?  Probably nothing as the Koreans are on the attack.  But it could have been a bit further forward.

The main battleline of heavy foot contracts as it advances.  The thought is if the Samurai Cavalry come their way, two units can turn and face them.

The Korean Cavalry advance to just out of bow reach.

A note about the sudden change in color from green to brown.  The camera's flash was set to "auto".  So that the left side of the field had insufficient light, so the flash went off, giving the field the correct coloration of green.  The right side of the field was judged sufficient light from the overhead lighting, but is a brown coloration found in florescent bulbs.  The overhead lights are 4 tubes of 5,000 kelvin LED's, but also one huge curly LED rated at 300w, but probably 2,700 kelvin, which dominates the color scheme.

For more on LED Lighting and an explanation on Kelvins, I wrote this article many years ago.

The Strategist orders his line to turn left and double march.

The remaining Japanese advance slightly and loose arrows.  Scoring two hits.

Turn 2:

Kim-Lar-Re advances to charge reach, his cavalry screened by lights from the massive volleys of arrows being put out by the Samurai.

The Samurai Cavalry/Foot command lines up with their remaining line and loose arrows. 

The contest between elite and ordinary begins, with predictable results.

Bonehead move!.  Both light horse are destroyed by archery, disordering the lancers behind them.

I honestly thought when a unit is routed by bow fire that it did not make a rout move.
I was wrong. (pg 61 para 1 and 2)   (and fully qualified for the dense on pg 23 in the FAQ)

The count at the Tree of Woe is 11-0

Turn 3:

The Wagons trundle along, focusing their firepower on the perceived axis of advance by the Samurai Horsemen.

Kim-Dar-el rallies one unit successfully.  He orders his Cataphracts forward to support Kim-Lar-Re's cavalry charge.

Because when you are down 11-0, and are out shot elite vs ordinary, the ONLY choice is to charge in and hope for luck to save your sorry butt.

And the results are: One "Followers with Bow"was destroyed, one Samurai disordered, two ties, and two losses.

One Samurai Horsemen is playing off the flank games with the War Wagon.  Which is fine by me as I have shots at this point.  Also it's a zero (elite) to 2 dice off.

The main Korean battleline is beginning to creak.

Despite being mostly disordered, the Korean shock cavalry is doing better than expected.  2 Samurai units killed to one horseman.

Bringing the score to 13-6 ( out of 21-19)

 Turn 4:

War Wagons score their first hit.

The real purpose of the War Wagons is to protect the flanks from cavalry.  Any scores from missile fire is considered a bonus.  Which is a good thing, as they only scored one hit the whole game.

The Korean Spear line buckles more, but that is why I bring Heavy Foot, they can take the punishment.  The Cataphracts charge in, nearly dispersing their opponents on impact.

The Cavalry charge trades a horse for a foot unit.  But has turned the flank of the Samurai.

The dead pile up at the Tree of Woe.

The Samurai Strategist decides it is worth his command points to swat the only Korean Light Foot.

In retrospect, he was right.

More buckling of the main line.  Korean spearmen are 4/6ths disordered, 1/6th dead to one Samurai disordered.

I am wondering when will the Samurai commit to swords, elite vs mediocre would be short work.  But Tom is content to just let the arrows fly.

The Cataphract destroys his opponent.  The Samurai bring up their reserves, preventing a flank charge by cavalry, and also flanking the Korean Horsemen.

At the bottom of the 4th, the score is 17-11

Turn 5:

More shooting on the left, a Samurai Horsemen is disordered.

Kim-Dar-El keeps trying to rally his troops, with some effect.

Two more Japanese foot units are destroyed.  One to Cataphracts in the way back, one to a flank charge.  But Kim-Lar-Re is going to suffer a flank charge as well, and he is fighting in the front lines.

The score is tightening, 15-16

The Japanese commander tries to rally, and fails.  His other horsemen line up for missile fire.  Another spearmen is destroyed.  But a Samurai horsemen is now in range and arc of the Hwacha!

The Koreans have fired over 60,000 bolts, and so far have only disordered one Samurai unit.

And you thought this was artistic license.

Kim-Lar-Re is flank charged, and his unit takes two hits, but he lives!

The pile of the dead is rising

Turn 6:

The Hwacha crew awakes from their nap and fires, but misses.  This despite 3 supporting shots.

Hwacha load of garbage.

Kim-Dar-El continues to rally.  He has forgotten about his Cataphracts in the rear.

He had the command points to move the Cataphracts.  He could have had them in strike range of the Japanese camp for turn 7, which could win the game.  Instead they were spent on 3 failed rallies.

A Guards Cavalry is destroyed, Kim-Lar-Re narrowly escapes to the adjacent Guards.

The game is very close 20-17  Each side is only 1-2 points from demoralization. 

Another shot of the Hwacha, with 3 supports!  Another miss. 

But the last straw is hit with a Korean Horse Guards taking the it's first hit.

Bringing the final score to 21-17.

What went wrong?

The Korean plan was solid.  The execution was flawed.  And it was all lost on the basics.  Don't have units in the rout path.  Totally stupid.  Especially since I had to deploy Tom's units, he was very specific how far back his reserves were to avoid the same problem.  Even with that error, the Koreans nearly broke through to the camp.

Other errors was the handling of the Korean Spear/Crossbow units.  I had two units on the left flank that were miss handled, and suffered an extra dead unit as a result.  

Then there was the Light Foot unit.  I ran it up in the rear of the Samurai Horsemen for an extra support shot.  Which failed, then the Lights was caught and killed.  Avoiding any one of those mistakes would have allowed the game to go to turn 7, and victory could have been had, or at least a mutual destruction.

Basement Civil War

A Headless Body Production
Venue:   An Undisclosed Basement

Event:    Playing a game for the camera 
Players: Phil Gardocki running Samurai
              Tom Worden running Anglo Irish
Game System: L'Art de la Guerre, 15mm, 200 points per side.

So there was a comment made to my last battle report, the Battle of Emesa from Tommy Worden, "...would you be up for a remote game of ADLG at some point via WhatsApp?"  I have no idea what is up with WhatsApp, but have played a couple virtual games on Table Top Simulator, so why not?  We go back and forth with the lists, and settle on Tom playing Anglo-Irish, and me Samurai.

Tom lives in Ireland, so basically, my phone was used to live stream the board, across the Trans-Atlantic cable. Pretty cool, huh?

The Forces:
Samurai (list 210)
The Samurai are commanded by Larry-San, the Competent, his brother Darryl-San the Brilliant and his other brother Darryl-San, the Ordinary and unreliable.
7 Samurai, Medium Swordsmen, Bow, 5 of which are Elite  
4 Yari, Medium Spearmen, Mediocre
6 Mounted Samurai, Heavy Cavalry, Bow, 2 of which are Elite  
4 Bowmen, Pavise, Mediocre
Breakpoint of 21

Anglo Irish
Commanded by Larry, Included and Ordinary, his brother Darrel the Competent, and his other brother Darrel, also Competent.
2 Heavy Knights, Impact, Elite,
2 Heavy Cavalry
4 Galloglaich, Heavy Swordsmen, 2HW, Elite
4 Billmen,  Heavy Swordsmen, 2HW
4 Kerns, Light Infantry, Javelin
2 Light Cavalry, Light Cavalry, Javelin
4 Longbowmen, 2 elite
Breakpoint of 22

The Board:
The Anglo Irish win the initiative and elect to defend in the plains.
However, all the terrain fell on the Samurai side of the board.

Near the Shannon River, the central plain of Ireland gently undulates.

 And by an amazing coincidence, the author lives in Limerick township.

The Anglo Irish Army deploys on the rivers edge, one flank secure with a steady supply of water.

The Japanese center command of 5 Samurai, and 2 Yari

Their right side command is 6 Heavy Cavalry, Bow.

A note about the sudden change in color from green to brown.  The camera's flash was set to "auto".  So that the left side of the field had insufficient light, so the flash went off, giving the field the correct coloration of green.  The right side of the field was judged sufficient light from the overhead lighting, but is a brown coloration found in florescent bulbs.  The overhead lights are 4 tubes of 5,000 kelvin LED's, but also one huge curly LED rated at 300w, but probably 2,700 kelvin, which dominated the color scheme.  I didn't realize what was happening till half way through the game. Sorry.  

For more on LED Lighting and an explanation on Kelvins, I wrote this article many years ago.

Turn 1:

Out of the gully pours out a large command of spear and bow.

The Samurai advance 1UD, and slide right.

The horse Samurai advance at a trot.

The Irish Light Horse advance and harass from behind the left flank of the Japanese army.

The main battle line of the Anglo-Irish advances one march.

It is along the River Shannon that the first attack of the Anglo-Irish will fall.  Heavy Knights supported by Heavy Cavalry and Longbow.

Turn 2:

Darryl-san rolled very well with command points.  He charges the Light Horse with a Samurai unit.  The Light Horse stood to receive, so Darryl-san then brought up a Yari to support.  But the luck was with the Irish as the Samurai took the hit.

The main line of Samurai advance to bow range and loose arrows.

The same with the Samurai horse.

The Irish Light Horse have done their best, breaking up the ranks of a the Samurai left command, and so break off.  Samurai loose a volley at their retreating horses.

The Irish battle line holds and rallies.

While the knights run off their tormentors.

Turn 3:

Another volley, and the Irish Lights are dispersed to the winds.

After which, the Samurai rally, and then break out the Saki to celebrate their victory.

A couple of units of spear and bow flank the Anglo-Irish line.

Their Samurai continue to expend sheaf after sheaf of arrows. 

The Shogun is not paying them to bring them back.

Samurai horse advance again and shoot.  A Yari takes up position to flank chargers if the Anglo-Irish charge again.

The Galloglaich advance and commit to battle.  The Billmen hang behind.

The Anglo-Irish horse successfully rally their losses.

Turn 4:

Darryl-san orders a charge.  It's elite longbow vs mediocre spear.  The spear roll poorly and take a hit.

The Galloglaich have left their screen of Kerns behind and now are experiencing the accuracy of Japanese shooting.

The horse archery is proving useless against the Knights armor.

Galloglaich charge.  A Yari is plowed under.

Fortune favors the bold, as Yari and Samurai begin to buckle under the bloody axes of the Galloglaich.  The Anglo Billmen take up position for the next charge.

The horns blow, signaling another charge.  Samurai horses tire and roll short on the evade.  Knight stallions give chase!

Turn 5:

The Longbow holding the flank is charged again, and collapses.  Mediocre Japanese archers take up position against the flanked Galloglaich.  But dare not approach any closer as they saw what happened to the  the last Yari, who had spears and shields!

The Samurai line continues to hold, but the Galloglaich are close to breaking through.

Samurai horsemen are out of room to retreat, and draw their swords. 

A lot of maneuvering, but not a lot of casualties.  The score is 6-5.

The Billmen join the fight.  But too late for the Galloglaich Clan O'Lyre as it is destroyed.

Another massive charge.  An Irish Noble is in trouble.

But the commander's knights blithely dismiss their opponents.

His brother knights and Irish Nobles also hack and slay.

And just like that, the score is now 12 all.

Turn 6:

The Longbow acting as flank guard is giving way.

The Boys from Stafford are now flanked but hold their ground.  Clan Ramsay is fighting hard, but giving ground.  The Billmens charge falters against some of the Samurai, but destroys another.

Chaos erupts in the cavalry fight as the superior numbers of the Samurai make themselves felt.  The Anglo General is flanked and killed.

The game is still nearly even, 15-14

At the bottom of the turn, almost nothing as changed.

The center scrum is a pretty even exchange.

The brother knights, outnumbered, but also with better armor and elite, stand their ground.  And give better then they got, causing 2 hits on their attackers.

The score is now 17-All!

Turn 7:
Both sides are now within 5 of demoralization.

Both Clan Ramsay the Boys from Stafford are destroyed.  The last Galloglaich stands, but is in very poor shape from archery fire.

A Billmen is defeated, but that is matched by a Yari being dispersed.

The cavalry fight continues.  The Japanese have a 3-2 edge in numbers, and still have their commander.

The final tally at the Tree of Woe, 22-17

So what went wrong with the Anglo-Irish? Their main battle line was turned and crumbled, just as their best troops were engaged frontally with weaker opponents.  The Irish had a 22 to 21 advantage in units, but the Japanese have no light troops.  One of the Irish Light Horse peeled off two units that never saw combat again, so in the end the main battle lines the Japanese had the advantage of 19 - 16.  

But the main problem, worked out afterwards was that Tommy was working with an extreme disadvantage with the views presented by the camera.  I needed to be more proactive in moving it about so that is views were optimal.