Location: Regency at Providence Community Center, Phoenixville, Pa
Event: Providence Gamer's Game Knight
Players: Phil Gardocki, Garth Parker playing the Early Swiss
Bruce Potter, Steve Turn, Mark McConnahay, playing the Inca
Game System: L'Art de la Guerre, about 200 points per side.
The Title: "The Eiger Sanction", what a stupid title. Other titles mulled over was "Climb Every Mountain", and "Andes vs. Alps"
Larry (Ordinary), Darryl (Brilliant) and Darryl (also Brilliant)
16 Halberdiers, Medium Swordsmen, 2HW, 12 are Elite
2 Light Cavalry Crossbow
3 Light Infantry Crossbow
Breakpoint of 22
Breakpoint of 22
Son of Atahualpa (Brilliant), 2 others, (both Competent)
24 Warriors, Medium Swordsmen
3 Light Infantry, Sling
Break point 28
Scenario: In perpetration for the Cold Wars Tournament, the battle will be fought in the Mountains. The only question is will it be in the Andes, or the Alps?
How did these armies get here?: No, I am not going to write some fantasy fiction to explain how these two armies could have met. No wizards, mysterious rifts in the fabric of space. No blue boxes wheezing about.
The Swiss, who would build an army of only medium swords men for this game? I painted the Swiss you see below in 1985. The game was WRG 6. In that game they were rated as Irreg'A'. Which means they would make an impetuous charge (approximately +66% damage) very easily, and to break they would have to lose 4 consecutive battles. I described them as a "Luck" army. No amount of bad luck was going to defeat them, and only a little bit was required for them to have amazing wins. But, while I was painting them, WRG 7 came out, and their advantages disappeared. Additionally, there was a brutal increase of the shield-less penalty which literally saw units disappear on contact. The Swiss were put in a can, and sat on my shelves for 30 years.
The Inca. Steve visited a mutual fried of ours, Ed (no last names), and played a WRG game. Ed was running the Inca. Steve admired the army and bought it off of Ed. Steve later commented, "In retrospect, maybe I shouldn't have bought an army that I just trounced."
The Swiss won the initiative and elected to defend in the Alps. They picked two steep wooded hills and an impassible. The Inca selected two brush.
|The Incan Commands were all pretty even, 8 warriors running 6 wide with 2 reserve warriors, and some shooters.|
|Their center command deploys in the brush, defending their otherwise defenseless camp.|
|On the Incan left, 8 more Warriors, defending 3 units worth of fortifications.|
|The "Men from Bern", deploy on the Swiss left.|
|Ignoring the walls provided for them, the Banner command cram onto the hill.|
The deployment of the Banner command was a fairly good idea. The Banner command, with quick moving Medium Infantry, can extend 4 elements either way if need be if they get a double move. So flexibility is maintained.
|Son of Atahualpa pushes his men forward, but they have to divert around the impassible. Possibly the Eiger 'snorth face?|
|The center advances on the double.|
|The Incan left seizes up, due to a lack of command points, and fear of a flank march.|
|The men from Bern have no shortage of command points, and triple march to go shoulder to shoulder with their counterparts on the hill.|
|The Banner command have spread out quite nicely.|
At this point I realized I made a strategic error. Not the first as it turned out, but the first discovered. The Men from Bern should have sent their Light Infantry left, to the other steep hill, just to run interference over there. It was going to be absolutely no use were it was.
|The Incas had to contract to get around the Eiger.|
|The Incan center slowed down to keep the line formed up.|
|The Incan left had a few more command points. Enough to move the mass forward twice.|
|The Men from Bern complete their line up. That Light Infantry I mentioned earlier was pulled out for redeployment. Unphotographed and to the left is an Incan Slinger sneaking around the edge.|
|The Banner Command also retires their Lights.|
|Is this sneakiness, clever planning, or just the tyranny of geometry? The Incas advance to within 5 mm of the front of the Swiss line. They have the advantage of the overlap here. But that was expected when you have a 24-16 edge in main combatants.|
|The Incan center brings up 4 elements to continue the line, but refuses on the left to challenge the hill. But deploys it's remaining forces well enough to cover the flank.|
|The Incan left, plagued with poor command point rolls, is late for the initial impact.|
|This suits the Swiss just fine. They know they are going to lose the flanks anyway, their strategy relying on quality to blow out the center before the flanks collapse.|
"When your only tool is a hammer, all your problems look like nails." --Abraham Maslow
|Victory followed victory, as undeserved good fortune prevailed down the Swiss line. 8 battles, 4 wins, 3 ties and a loss.|
But what are the odds here? The combat statistics page on the official L' Art de la Guerre site breaks it down this way. If all the battles are even, and in this case only two were not, the Incas had a +2 to + 1 on the Swiss left, and the Swiss had the same edge on the right, then with Elite vs Normal combat, the Swiss should win 50%, tie 17%, lose 33%, so in the case above, the Swiss won right on average with 4, the but pulled extra ties that made it look so bad for the Inca. Also, with the 2HW, 2 of the Swiss victories scored a +1 damage, which in one case, lead to the destruction of a warrior, disordering it's rear support.
The Swiss have 1 point towards their demoralization level of 22.
The Inca have 6 points towards their demoralization level of 28.
|The Inca push forward on the left flank of the Swiss with a column of Warriors.|
|The Inca left flank makes contact.|
|The dead piled high in front of the Swiss Kiels.|
The Inca have 17 points towards their demoralization level of 28.
We thought this game wouldn't go the time limit. And it looks like that will be true.
|Undaunted by the carnage, the Son of Atahualpa pushes his flank attack. A Swiss Kiel falls, most of the kiels remaining are disordered.|
|On the Incan left, the Warriors swarm the barricades, slaying the defenders to a man. But on the hill, a warrior unit is also destroyed, and their flank exposed.|
|Every last Inca Warrior unit (10) in the center has been destroyed. But can the Swiss save their camp?|
|Even on the hill, where the Incan had about a 2-1 edge, the Swiss have lost a Kiel, and that by desperate action by the Incan commander leading from the front, but otherwise the Swiss are either holding their ground or gaining.|
|<Queue the William Tell Overture> The Swiss Cavalry has arrived, and will sack the Incan camp next turn.|
It looks really bad for the Inca, but when we counted the points, the score is much closer than we thought. The Inca have a lot of dead units but what is left is undisordered. While only a few Swiss are undamaged.The Swiss have 17 points towards their demoralization level of 22.
The Inca have 23 points towards their demoralization level of 28.
Both sides are 5 away from demoralization. Both sides have assaults primed for the camps. The Inca have several flank attacks lined up, while the Swiss literally have no targets to go for.
|It is down to one die roll, on a 5 or a 6, the Swiss will lose this game.|
The Swiss have 18 points towards their demoralization level of 22.
The Inca have 23 points towards their demoralization level of 28.
The Swiss have 19 points towards their demoralization level of 22.
The Inca have 28 points towards their demoralization level of 28.
|Following their final orders, Inca Slingers arrive to defend the camp, but too little, too late.|
From Hell's heart, I stab at thee; For hate's sake, I spit my last breath at theeAh, but it was not to be.
Read more at: https://www.brainyquote.com/quotes/herman_melville_390294
Another strategic mistake on the Swiss side was the placement of the fortifications.
On the far right, I placed them right up to the edge of the hill. Normally I would place them about 1/2 to 3/4 a UD away. Enough to cover the area, but leaving a gap that no one can sneak through without hitting the terrain. This caused us almost to lose the game, as when the battle on the right developed, we wanted to retire the right two units to avoid them being overwhelmed. But between the fortifications, and losing a UD of movement for the turn, we were unable to do it, and so had to stand there and take the fight. The end result lead to the Inca destroying 4 units for 8 points. I know we destroyed 6 points as well, but that was mainly luck.