A Grievance of Scots

A Headless Body Production
Venue: On Military Matters Bookstore. Owner Operator: Dennis Shorthouse

Event: Prep for USTT 2020


Players: Phil Gardocki running Burgundian Ordinance
George Brown running Medieval Scots
Game System: L'Art de la Guerre, 15mm, 200 points per side.
Theme: None

The Forces:

Burgundian Ordonnance

Commanded by Lawrence, the Competent, his brother Darryl (Which turns out to be French in origin) the Competent and his other brother Darryl , the Ordinary, and somewhat unreliable.
5 1/2 Heavy Spearman 1/2 Longbowmen
2 Foot Knights
3 Men-at-Arms, Heavy Knight, Impact, 1 Elite
2 Light Cavalry, Crossbow
2 Demi-Lancers, Heavy Cavalry Impact
2 Handgunners, Elite
2 Crossbow, Pavise

Breakpoint of 20

Medieval Scots

4 Highlanders, Medium Swordsmen, Bow
7 Pike, Mediocre
4 Foot Knights, French, Elite
1 Levy
4 Longbowmen

Breakpoint of 21

Dennis has a wonderful bookstore in Hopewell New Jersey, that he has been running for many decades. Imagine going through a library that is nothing but military history. If you don't think you knew him, he is a long time supporter of Historical Miniatures Gaming Society, and held the coveted #1 spot in the dealers area for over 20 years. So if you have been to any of HMGS's events at the Lancaster Host, you probably have met Dennis at some time.


The Board:
The Burgundians win the initiative and elect to attack in the plains.

The defense has all the terrain. This is going to suck.

Yep, there they are, all behind the rough.

Darryl's command here is just 2 heavy foot, and two crossbowmen, and a light infantry. His mission is to hold the flank and collapse gracefully under pressure on defense. Attacking is something he doesn't do.

This is what is known as a "Dense Pack" You may get the Ronald Regan reference here.

Lawrence can match the length of the Scots line, but not the depth.

But were is his other brother Darryl?

Turn 1:

Burgundian Hand Gunners head for the field. They don't have to hold it, just deny it as a launching point for a while.

The rest of Darryl's command advances on the double.

Keeping in lock step with Lawrence's line.

An ambush is revealed! The famous Medium Sword Bowmen.

These are not half sword, half bowmen, which melee as mediocre's, but all sword bow, which fight as ordinary. They are kind of rare in LADG, the only other example I can think of are Samurai. 

The rest of the Scots swarm over the hill! Their Longbow forming up just out of the 4UD "Panic" area on the flank.

Turn 2:
The unseen Burgundian command rolls a six, and will arrive next turn.

The Burgundians advance to bow range and loose arrows. This is working out well as the Scots Longbow are getting set to receive the flank march, and are not involved much in the exchange. I have 7 shooters at optimal range, this works for me.

The left flank though is in jeopardy. The Scots have enough force to squash Darryl's command like an snake on highway 10.

Burgundian archery has found their range.

The Scots have 4 points towards their breakpoint of 21
The Burgundians have 1 point towards their breakpoint of 20

Turn 3:

The Burgundian left command's mission is to live as long as possible. So the Handgunners swing left and out of range, and the Crossbowmen retreat to safety. Leaving the Pike to hold the line.

With some clever pivoting, if the Scots race across the field into the pike, they will be flank charged in return.

Darryl's knights charge onto the field. One longbowmen flees, and is subsequently fletched to death. The rest hold their ground and loose arrows.

I decided to not make the camp a priority, and so only lights are on the far right, to go for support and wrap around attacks.

The Scots begin the long turn of the flank. Missile men making themselves felt.

The Scots plan seems to be to crush the Burgundian left, while daring the Burgundians to ascend the hill.

The hill is field covered, and so is -2 to spearmen, but only -1 to the foot knights. And the Burgundian Spearmen fight as Mediocre, and the swordsmen have 2 handed swords and Armor. It would be very bad for the Burgundians.

The Longbow darken the skies. One Burgundian Knight is disordered twice, but the rest hold firm.

Turn 4:

It's the kind of charge we dream about when you run knights. All in a line, their enemy fleeing before contact. Rolling a pair of 6's and a 5 is just icing on the cake.

Darryl turns his crossbow at just the range where if the pike are flanked, then the flankers are flanked.

The Scot's are not going to allow this at all.

Neither are they going to allow a flank charge of their frontal forces.

And while the Scot's forces are forming up to defend their rear, the Burgundian missile fire is thinning their ranks.

Turn 5:

Darryl abandons his crossbowmen to their fate.

And goes for the hill anyway! His Pike are holding, his spearmen are actually fighting in the flat while the Scot's pike are in the field. His other spearmen have support against a disordered foot knight.

Burgundian knights ascend the hill They don't get impact, but there are flanks and rears everywhere from that position.

The swarm of Scots begin to overrun the Burgundian flanks.

It's official, the proper plurality for Scots is "Swarm"

Their units on the hill are heavily disordered.

The Scot's rear continues to firm up despite casualties.

The Scots have 15 points towards their breakpoint of 21
The Burgundians have 7 points towards their breakpoint of 20
Turn 6:

At this point George conceded.

Even when the Burgundian camp falls, there was so many Scot's units that were vulnerable, and fresh units of Burgundians available that victory was inevitable.

So what went wrong? The traffic jam in the right corner was a serious problem. I needed to start turning the infantry a turn earlier.

Bringing up the crossbowmen with the line was a mistake. If I had just left them behind they would have gotten two more shots in, and accepting counter fire with pavise.

A Magnificence of Mongols

A Headless Body Production
Venue: On Military Matters Bookstore. Owner Operator: Dennis Shorthouse

Event: Prep for Cold Wars 300 point Team Tournament
Players: Phil Gardocki running Samurai
               Dennis Shorthouse running Mongols
Game System: L'Art de la Guerre, 15 mm, 300 points per side.
Theme: None

The Forces:
Samurai
Aishi and Dishi, both Brilliant, Bishi and Cishi, both Competent
10 Mounted Samurai, Heavy Cavalry, Bow, Elite
6 Samurai, Medium Swordsmen, Bow, Elite
6 Yari, Medium Spearmen, Mediocre
6 Archers, Bowmen, Pavise, Mediocre
4 Enishi, Light Cavalry, Bow

Breakpoint around 30

Mongols

This is mostly guesswork

10 Medium and Heavy Cavalry, Bow, Elite and some Impact

12 Light Cavalry, Bow, 1/2 Elite

6 Levy Expendable

Breakpoint of 38

Dennis has a wonderful bookstore in Hopewell New Jersey, that he has been running for many decades. Imagine going through a library that is nothing but military history. If you don't think you knew him, he is a long time supporter of Historical Miniatures Gaming Society, and held the coveted #1 spot in the dealers area for over 20 years. So if you have been to any of HMGS's events at the Lancaster Host, you probably have met Dennis at some time.

The Board:

The Mongols win the initiative and elect to attack in the plains.

The Mongol right hand command is 3 units of lights, and 3 mediums.

The Mongol center right has 4 units of lights, and 3 Heavy Cavalry, Impact, Bow

As part of the same command, are 6 units of Levy

On the left are their heaviest forces.  6 cavalry, and 10 lights.

Cishi takes the left with 8 units, 4 bow, 4 spear, all of questionable families and talents.

The center has all the foot samurai, supported by Yari.

On the right are two commands of Samurai cavalry, all heavies, elites and with bows.  Commanded by the Brilliant commanders Aishi and Dishi

 The unflocked units are from my soon to be finished Korean army.

 Turn 1:

Taking full advantage of mobility, and of a faulty deployment on the Japanese side, the Mongols decide to cut a couple of units from the herd and earmark them for destruction.

 The hill is covered in a field as well, I should have just put all 8 units on it instead.

The Mongol heavies head for the weaker Yari units.  They levy has been assigned to combat the Samurai foot forces.

But on the Mongol left there is a problem, as they are outnumbered in both quantity and quality, and matched in mobility and command.

But for the moment, Mongol arrows fly true, disordering the Japanese lights, and exposing the flank.

Cishi has two command points.  One orders the turning of a Yari to prevent envelopment, the other directs bow fire.

Samurai advance and loose arrows.

The mounted Samurai likewise. 

Considering the volume of elite shooters, this was not a promising beginning.

The other lights have bee withdrawn, but it took a lot of doing to get the heavies in the way to prevent pursuit.

Turn 2:

The Mongols race through the arrow storm and set up a two prong attack on a Yari.

With the attention of the Samurai diverted to the Levi, 3 Mongol lancers are bearing down on the flank protecting Yari

The missile exchange against the Mounted Samurai is running in the favor of the Mongols.

The Mongols keep up the pressure on the far flank.

Yari charge off the light horse, with archers blowing them a kiss as they run.

The Yari in the middle are holding their ground, with support coming up on their right.  The foot Samurai have had enough of this shooting at worthless troops and give them the sword instead.

By some miracle, some of the levy still stands.

On the left, Mongol Medium Cavalry is trapped, then charged.  Their general decides not to ride off and support his compatriot.  Aishi then decides to charge their supporting light horse as well  figuring that their either flee, and that will be OK, or stay, and he will have elite heavies against lights, and that's OK as well.

Mid-battle summertime

where a tempered, frothed horse charge
whilst waving the sword

The remaining Samurai line continues shooting, and has 5 successful rallies as well.

Glorious mid-day
How a many, curved bows throbbed
Arrows loft fluttered

The Samurai have 2 points towards their breakpoint of 30
The Mongols have 7 points towards their breakpoint of 29

Turn 3:

A Yari is swarmed and overwhelmed.

So too, the Samurai flank guards.

In the center, the Levi is scattered, along with a Mongol Cavalry unit.  But a careless placement has put Aishi in the path of a flank charge.  But fortune favors fools, and he avoids a death roll, and wins the fight.

One unit of Mongol cavalry advances to block ZOC for the flank charge, the rest stand and shoot.

Cishi focuses his bow fire to no avail

Mongol lancers finish job 1, but now are facing a new threat.

Samurai foot advance on new targets.

There is nothing like the feeling of destroying 5 enemy levy, and have the breakpoint counter advance by zero.
Well played Dennis.

It seems like the Samurai have the cavalry battle well in hand.  Red arrows show possible future paths.

The Samurai have 9 points towards their breakpoint of 30
The Mongols have 9 points towards their breakpoint of 29

Turn 4:

 

A Mongol general rallies the last Levy unit.  He is trying to avoid having his best cavalry from being surrounded.  Red arrows show unit facing.  Rules note, it was discovered later that expendable Levys cannot rally.

The Mongols have their right flank fight well in hand.  But it will take time to clean up the remaining blocking forces.

The Mongol Heavies can either charge the Yari/Bowmen, which are Mediocre but organized, or the Samurai, which is Elite, but poorly positioned.  They go for the Samurai.

The Mongol horse could only have gotten two units engaged of the Yari/Bowmen group, but that group has an ordinary commander, and is currently out of command range.

With half their leaders dead, the Mongols decide to hold their ground.

Their options limited to covering one flank and a failed rally.

Cishi flees his flank guard to bolster his more orderly command.

He orders his bowmen forward.  He chose this because there was Mongol Light Cavalry unit in range to charge their rear. 

In retrospect he should have accepted that charge and pushed his spearmen instead.

Total chaos here.  Battles won that should be lost and visa-versa.  The Mongols call retreat where they are at risk. 

This is all the more confusing with my dark flocking making it difficult to tell which way the units are facing.

All the Mongol Heavies are now trapped, but their win isn't on this flank.

The Samurai have 16 points towards their breakpoint of 30
The Mongols have 15 points towards their breakpoint of 29

Turn 5:

Half of Cishi's command is in ruins.  But the Mongols are in disarray as well.

A bad decision comes back to bite.  Aishi's bowmen are eviscerated, while his Yari are in no position to help.

Bishi's foot Samuri advance to the area but can provide little support

On their left flank, the Mongol heavies are still engaged, but refuse to die.

Time has been called, so the bottom of the turn is all that is left.

Samurai line up on a single heavy

The cleanup on far right continues.

There is no point in pursuing the lights, so  rallies are in order.

The final score
The Samurai have 23 points towards their breakpoint of 30
The Mongols have 13 points towards their breakpoint of 29

The battle ran with both sides winning on their right flanks.  But on the Samurai left, the Mongols were able to take advantage of the situation better as their mobility allowed them to keep destroying units.

While on the Samurai right, the last of the Mongol heavies still stood his ground, and all the lights were able to escape.

The middle of the field was where the battle was lost.  The foot Samurai's only targets for several turns was the Levy units.  Tying up a very expensive asset for zero gain for several turns.  If those elite, and +1 vs mounted, bows were allowed real targets, this game would have had a different ending.

Violent sundown
A total, bloody loss failed
at the perfect bows